Thanks to Kawaue san

This counts PC accesses only.

Why does "kumdo"
tell a lie ?

Pourquoi ils disent
un mensonge avec le "kumdo" ?

Sorry for my infrequent updates.


A Happy New Year !

What is the "kumdo" problem?

The problem is that not a few associations spread the fabricated fact
that Kendo belongs to the Korean culture.

They carry out propaganda activities around the world.
They call Kendo "kumdo", which is the pronunciation of Kendo in Korean.

Around the world, they open many Dojo (Kendo training rooms), host games,
give demonstrations and give their practitioners licenses of ranks.

Do they have any relationship with Japanese associations?
No. They often carry out such activities without any relationships to Japan.

They also use the Shinai(a bamboo sword) and Bougu (protective gear) of Kendo.
But they often change the procedure of the games and their costumes.

After all, their "kumdo" is a copy of Kendo.
What makes them do such activities?

One of the reasons appears to be that they never want to accept
the fact that Kendo was imported from Japan when Korea was ruled by Japan.
But can such a reason justify their cultural invasion?
(This is nothing but cultural invasion.)

Is there a "kumdo" Dojo in your town?

Qu'est-ce que c'est le probleme "kumdo" ?

C'est un probleme car beaucoup d'associations repandent
des mensonges autour du "Kendo", qui appartient a la culture coreene.

Ils appellent "Kendo" "kumdo", qui est la prononciation coreene.
Ils propagent ces activites au titre des coreens dans le monde entier.

Ils ouvrent beaucoup de "Dojo" (la salle a faire du Kendo),
organisent des matches, presentent les arts militaires,
et decernent leurs licences de Dan (le grade de Kendo) dans le monde entier.

Est-ce qu'ils ont un rapport avec les associations japonaises ?
NON. Ils n'ont aucun rapport dans la plupart des cas.

Ils se servent souvent du "Shinai" (le sabre de bambou)
et du "Bougu"(l'equipement pour se defendre) du Kendo.
Mais ils changent frequemment les methodes des matches et ces equipements.

Finalement, leur "kumdo" est une copie du "Kendo".
Pourquoi en font-ils ?

On suppose que c'est parce qu'ils ne veulent pas convenir
que le "Kendo" a ete importe du Japon quand le Japon gouvernait la Coree.
Mais peuvent-ils s'approprier la culture pour cette raison ?
(On ne peut plus dire que c'est une invasion de la culture.)

Est-ce qu'il y a "kumdo" Dojo dans votre ville ?













1. A lot of lies in "kumdo" homepage 1. "コムド" ホームページの多くの嘘

(1)""Part (2005/07/31 Updated)(2013/4/27 Corrected link )
(1)"コムド・コム"Part (2005/07/18 Updated)(2013/4/27 Corrected link )

(2)"haidong gumdo"Part (2011/04/30 Updated)
(2)"海東剣道"Part (2011/04/30 Updated)

(3) "F.A.Q."Part (2005/09/24 Updated)
(3) "F.A.Q."Part (2005/09/24 Updated)

2. About this pages and me 2. このウェブサイト(ホームページ)と私について

(1) Who am I ? (2004/1/26)

(2) F.A.Q. about My Web Pages (2005/11/27)
(2) 私のウェブについてのF.A.Q. (2005/11/27)

3. Link 3. リンク

BBS for this web English Help is here!
こ のwebのためのBBS

Other links (2007/03/04 Updated)
その他のリンク(2007/03/04 Updated)

4. Theme of Today 4. 今日のテーマ

(1) Why? make no reference to the Treaty of Shimonoseki

(1) なぜ下関条約のことを話さないのか?

(2) Why do they invade Japanese culture ?

(2) なぜ日本の文化を侵略するのか?

(3) The background of their culture(2005/07/03, 2006/03/19)
(3) 彼らの文化の背景
(2005/07/03, 2006/03/19)

(4) How do they think of their history in the raw ?

(4) ありのままの歴史をどう考えていたのか?

(5) Was President Park a traitor ? (2005/11/13,12/29,2006/06/10)
(5) 朴大統領は売国奴か ? (2005/11/13, 2006/06/10)

(6) The Change and Background of "Uriginal" Phenomenon (2006/01/22,02/05)
(6) 「ウリジナル」現象の変容と背景 (2006/01/22,02/05)

(7) Nations both close geographically and very distant culturally (2006/04/22)
(7) 場所が近いだけで実はとっても遠い国 (2006/04/22)

(8) (See Data Room)
(8) (資料室へ移動)  

(9) Wonderful sporting sprit of Korea (2006/06/03)
(9) 素晴らしき韓国式スポーツ精神 (2006/06/03)

(10) The characteristics and fundamentals of their behavior in World Cup 2006 (2006/07/23)
(10) ワールドカップ2006にみる彼らの行動の特徴と原理 (2006/07/23)

(11) Shameless sports culture trampled on kids' feelings (2006/09/03)
(11) 恥知らずのスポーツ文化は子供たちの心を踏みにじった (2006/09/03)

(12) The pioneer of cultural invasion, "taekwondo" (2006/09/17)
(12) 文化侵略のパイオニア、「テコンドー」 (2006/09/17)

(13) Many words from Japan (2006/10/01)
(13) 日本由来の多くの言葉 (2006/10/01)

(14) Koreanization (2006/12/21-2007/01/31)
(Part1) What is Koreanization?
(Part2) Why Koreanization?
(Part3) The three aspects of "koreanization"
(Part4) The 4th phase of "koreanization"

(14) コリアナイゼーション (2006/12/21-2007/01/31)
(Part1) コリアナイゼーションとは?
(Part2) コリアナイゼーションの理由
(Part4)「コリアナイゼーション」の4番目の局 面

(15) Sports scenes under Japanese rule (2007/02/18)
(15) 日本統治時代のスポーツの風景 (2007/02/18)

(16) We should keep watch on a habitual criminal. (2007/03/04)
(16) 常習犯は監視すべし。 (2007/03/04)

(17) The power of absurdity, the power of delusions (2007/03/18)
(17) 非常識力、妄想力 (2007/03/18)

(18) The reactions of Korean media and people to "Virginia Tech massacre"
(Part1) (2007/04/29)
(Part2) (2007/05/06)
(Part3) (2007/06/06)

(18) バージニア工科大虐殺事件についての韓国メディアと韓国人の反応
(Part1) (2007/04/29)
(Part2) (2007/05/06)
(Part3) (2007/06/06)

(19) Japanese novels boom annoys Korean people (2007/06/23)
(19) 韓国人を悩ます日本小説ブーム (2007/06/23)

(20) Apostates (2007/07/24)
(20) 背教者たち (2007/07/24)

(21) It's not uncommon in Korea (2007/10/19)
(21) 韓国ではよくあること (2007/10/19)

(22) The incident in Beijing Olympic (2008/08/24)
(22) 北京オリンピックでの出来事 (2008/08/24)

(23) Seoul(Keijoh) boom and their hisitory as it should have been (2008/12/31)
(23) 京城ブームとあるべき歴史 (2008/12/31)

(24) "Haidong gumdo" demonstration in Japan Expo?
(Part1) (2011/05/29)(2011/08/10Updated)
(Part2) (2011/09/04)

(24) Japan Expoで海東剣道デモ?
(Part1) (2011/05/29)(2011/08/10 更新)
(Part2) (2011/09/04)

(25) The "Hate" nation constructed by "Hate" education (2012/03/31)
(25) ヘイト教育がつくる憎悪の国 (2012/03/31)

(26) The new legend of the thief nation, Korea
(part1) (2013/04/22)
(part2) (2013/05/07)
(part3) (2013/08/24)

(26) 韓国の新たなる泥棒国家伝説
(part1) (2013/04/22)
(part2) (2013/05/07)
(part3) (2013/08/24)

(27) So-called comfort-women problem
(part1)Obama has a hand in racial discrimination(2014/07/16)
(part2) Was Park Geun-hye's father a national pander? (2014/09/15)

(27) いわゆる慰安婦問題
(part1) 人種差別に加担するオバマ (2014/07/16)
(part2) パククネの父は国家的女衒だった? (2014/09/15)

5. Data Room 5. 資料室

(1) A Sample of petit Sinocentrism (From "Korea and Her Neighbours") (2005/12/11)
(1) 小中華思想のサンプル("朝鮮紀行"より) (2005/12/11)

(2) King of Korea declared independence from China with reluctance (From "Korea and Her Neighbours") (2006/01/06)
(2) 朝鮮王は渋々中国から独立を宣言した ("朝鮮紀行" より) (2006/01/06)

(3) How President Park talk about Korean history? (From "The selected works of Park Chunghee Volume 2") (2006/01/08)
(3) 朴大統領は韓国の歴史をどう思っていたのか? ("朴大統領選集第二巻"より) (2006/01/08)

(4) Samples of anti-Japan education (From "Wind of skirt") (2006/01/14) 
(4) 反日教育のサンプル ("スカートの風"より)(2006/01/14)

(5) Many differences in backgrounds (From "Korean wife is a good wife!?") (2006/04/02)
(5) 文化の相違をまとめました ("妻をめとらば韓国人!?" より) (2006/04/02)

(6) When I feel Korea has different culture from Japan (From "Wind of skirt") (2006/04/15)
(6) 韓国は日本とは異文化の国だと思うとき ("スカートの風"より )(2006/04/15)

(7) Feelings of inferiority causes Anti-Japan feelings(From "Koreans' historical view") (2006/04/16)
(7) 「劣等感」が反日の基本的要因("韓国人の歴史観"より) (2006/04/16)

(8) Ancient Japan expanded to Korean Peninsula.(From Japanese newspaper's article) (2006/05/20)
(8) 古代日本の朝鮮半島進出 (日本の新聞より)(2006/05/20)

(9) The case of Origami - Other cultural invasion (From Japanese newspaper's article) (2006/06/20)
(9) 「折り紙」の場合-その他の文化侵略の例 (日本の新聞より)(2006/06/20)

(10) An anti-Japan activity;The case of a president (From a Blog) (2006/04/23) (2006/07/3 Updated)
(10) 反日行為:ある社長の場合 (あるBlogより)(2006/04/23) (2006/07/3 更新)

(11) A Japanese female journalist living in Seoul talks about the fear of exclusive nationalism (From Korean newspaper's site) (2006/08/01)
(11) ソウル在住、日本人女性ジャーナリストが語る排他的民族主義の恐怖 (韓国紙サイトより)(2006/08/01)

(12) A sample of propaganda activities by a Korean official organization (From Japanese newspaper's article) (2006/08/13)

(12) 韓国の公的団体によるプロパガンダの例(日本の新聞より) (2006/08/13)

(13) A sample of propagand by a Korean major media and a famous actor. Supported by Korean official Kendo association?(From Korean newspaper's site) (2006/08/27)
(13) 韓国大手マスコミと有名俳優によるプロパガンダの例、バックは韓国の公式剣道団体?(韓 国紙サイトより) (2006/08/27)

(14) Korean people's distinct view of Japan(From Japanese newspaper's article) (2006/09/23)
(14) 韓国人の個性的対日観(日本の新聞より) (2006/09/23)

(15) How the fabricated history of taekwondo was exposed?(From an article on BBS) (2006/10/14)
(15) テコンドーの歴史捏造が露見するまで(翻訳掲示板記事より) (2006/10/14)

(16) Korean Cultural Center does not write the modern history of Korean soy sauce(From an article on BBS) (2006/10/27)
(16) 韓国文化院(政府組織)が書かない韓国の醤油の近代史(翻訳掲示板記事より) (2006/10/27)

(17) The truth of today's Korean rice (From an article on BBS) (2006/11/03)
(17) 現在の韓国米の真実 (翻訳掲示板記事より) (2006/11/03)

(18) We never accept capitalist economy was introduced by Japan! (From "Offspring of Empire") (2007/04/07)
(18) 「資本主義経済が日本から伝わったなんて認めたくない!」 (「日本帝国の申し子」より) ((2007/04/07))

(19) The shameful footprints of liars (2007/09/02)
(19) 嘘つきどもの恥ずべき足跡 (2007/09/02)

(20) "Mr. taekwondo" Choi Hong Hi spoke.
(Part1) How was taekwondo born? (2007/11/19)
(Part2) Naming problem (2008/01/06)
(Part3) Crimes for culture, culture for pride (2008/07/21)
(Part4) What Choi never said (2008/11/08)

(20)「ミスターテコンドー」チェホンヒが語 るテコンドー誕生秘話
(Part1) こうしてテコンドーは生まれた (2007/11/19)
(Part2) 名称問題 (2008/01/06)
(Part3) 文化のための犯罪、自負心のための文化 (2008/07/21)
(Part4) チェが決して言わなかったこと (2008/11/08)

(21) "Joseon Dynasty = Inca Empire" theory reveals the pathology of Korea (2011/10/05)
(21) 「李朝=インカ帝国」説が明らかにする韓国の病理 (2011/10/05)

(22) Does Korean government support a suspect group? (2011/10/18)
(22) 韓国政府が援助している怪しい集団? (2011/10/18)

(23) How was haidong gumdo born? (2012/01/20)
(23) こうして海東剣道は生まれた (2012/01/20)

(24) Culture of Lie (2013/01/14)
(24) 嘘の文化 (2013/01/14)

6. Rest Room 6. 休憩室

(1) Korean Problem Solving Flowchart (2006/03/02)
(1) 韓国式問題解決法 (2006/03/02)

(2) "NEET" originated from Korea? (2006/04/16)
(2) NEET(ニート)は朝鮮起源? (2006/04/16)

(3) What happened at Japan EXPO in France? (2006/08/10)
(3) フランスのジャパンEXPOで何が起こったのか? (2006/08/10)

Theme of Today

200,000 comfort women for US Army



Key passage:

"Yong Ju Gol", comfort women for US Army have much longer history than comfort women for Japanese Army. Then unlike comfort women for Japanese Army, "Yong Ju Gol" are considered to have numbered over 200,000!

But we can see "over 200,000" on the comfort woman for Japanese Army statue. If someone must use "over 200,000", he(she) should use correct country name and correct date in the light of true history. This inscription  should also be corrected.

Then Korean government and some American politicians should pay compensation and apologize for "their" comfort women as they have asked Japanese government. They must be responsible for their word.

要 約:

洋公主すなわち米軍慰安婦は、日本軍慰安婦と違い、その歴史の長さから20万人以上いたと考えられて います。




1. Who are "more than 200,000 Comfort women?

We can often hear incredible "experiences" from "comfort women for Japanese Army" as already noticed. They look like they have seen helicoptors and jeeps in Japanese Army during WWII. They also look like they have witnessed Japanese solders have gotten the Christmas holidays. But such experiences are just predictable ones if they had been comfort women for US Army.

When a "comfort women" related her experience to a French media in 2013, she coughed up "In Korean War days...".

Additionally we can also explain why some of "comfort women" were too young at the time of WWII. At least some of them were comfort women for US Army. It is more reasonable to think so.

The history of comfort women for US Army is over half-century long. The women involved has already numbered in significant number. A professor of Hiroshima university named Choe Kilsung estimates the number of comfort women for US Army in Korea at  30 hundreds of thousands from 25 hundreds of thousands till 1990("Sexual assaults and prostitution by UN force during Korean War").

When their compensation claims will be expanded, this may develop into much larger issue than comfort women for Japanese Army.

At this time comfort women for US Army claims against Korean government, but it is just a matter of time before they inquire into the responsibilityturn of US government.
There were only a few common informers five years ago(on NY Times (January 2009)). But now 122 complainants have appeared. Aftertime how many complainants will appear?

I want to point out one more thing.

2. Correct the inscription! Be responsible for your words!  

There are the letters of "more than 200,000 .. women" in the inscription on comfort women's statue at Glendale as if it had been an irrefutable fact of history. This figure of 200,000 does not have any basis but also outstrips the reality. Anyone who has normal intellectual ability is forced to acknowledge this by right. Because the number of overseas Japanese soldiers(army) were only 3,000,000 even at the end of WWII. This figure includes disabled soldiers and soldiers on the road. However the irresponsible politicians of USA likes to quote this figure. They want to use "more than 200,000" no matter what. Do they think "a few thousand" or "tens of thousands" is underwhelming?

In the meantime a councilwoman of Glendale, who cooperated for erecting comfort woman statue, said "… look at this monument(comfort woman statue) not as a blame or shame to any nation, but to remind us that war has consequences,"( on Glendale News-Press(July 2013)).

Then it would be simple. Anyone who wants to use "more than 200,000" only have to talk about "Yong Ju Gol", comfort women for US Army instead. Anyone doesn't think it's an exaggeration to say that they have reached into more than 200,000. The politicians can give vivid speeches about women's human rights and horrors of war. It is not necessary to change "more than 200,000" in the inscription. It is only necessary that the rest part will be changed for "Yong Ju Gol" instead. But now I will talk this figure may be in the right. However, I don't mean comfort women Japanese Army. 
However the irresponsible politicians of USA quote this figure many times.

1. 「二十万人以上の慰安婦」とは誰のことか?

前に書きましたが、自称元日本軍慰安婦にはしばしば 荒唐無稽な「体験談」が見られます。彼女らは、第二次世界大戦の日本軍の中でヘリコプターやジープを見たり、 日本軍兵士がクリスマス休暇をとっていたりしたらしいのです。しかし、これらの経験は、 米軍慰安婦だったとすればありきたりな体験談になるのです。

ある元慰安婦は、2013年のフランスのメディアの取材において 自らの体験を「朝鮮戦争のとき・・」と口を滑らせました。

さらに第二次世界大戦当時の彼女らの年齢が時に若すぎることも同様に説明がつきます。少なくとも彼女らの 一部は、米軍慰安婦であったと考えた方が合理的です。

米軍慰安婦の歴史は実に半世紀以上に渡ります。関わった女性もかなりの人数になります。 崔吉城(チェ・キルソン)という広島大の教授は1990年までに韓国における米軍相手の婦は25万から30万にのぼったとしています。 (「朝鮮戦争における国連軍の性暴行と売春」)。

彼女らの賠償請求が一大訴訟に 発展した 場合、その数から、日本軍慰安婦の比ではない相当大きな問題に発展する可能性があります。

5年前告発者はわずか数人に過ぎませんでした(NYTimes 2009年1月)。現在122人の原告が現れました。 今後何人の原告が現れるのでしょうか?


2. 碑文を修正し、言葉の責任をとれ!

グレンデール市の慰安婦の碑文には「20万人」の慰安婦というものが疑うべくもない歴史的事実であるかのように書かれています。 この数字は根拠がなく、また海外の日本兵の数(大戦末期でもせいぜい300万人、傷病兵、移動中の兵も含む)から真実とほど遠いことは、 まともな知的能力のある人なら認めざるを得ないところであります。 しかしながら米国の無責任な政治家たちはこの数字を好んで引用します。数千人や数万人では迫力に欠けるんでしょうか?どうしても この数字は外せないようです。

一方、グレンデール市の慰安婦像建立に協力した女性議員は 「少女像(慰安婦像)は特定の国の名誉を傷つけたり責めたりするのではなく、戦争がもたらしたものを 想起させる像として見てほしい」と発言しています(2014年7月、Glendale News-Press)。

ならば話は簡単です。「20万人以上」を使いたければ、代わりに洋公主、米軍用慰安婦の話をすればいいのです。 累計20万人以上と言っても誰も誇張とは思いません。女性の人権、戦争のもたらす弊害について迫力のある話ができることで しょう。また碑文の"20万人以上"はそのままで米軍慰安婦の内容に換えればいいのです!



((Current inscription))
In memory of more than 200,000 Asian and Dutch women who were removed from their homes in Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, the Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam, Malaysia, East Timor and Indonesia, to be coerced into sexual slavery by the Imperial Armed Army of Japan between 1932 and 1945. 

((Proposed revision))
In memory of more than 200,000 Asian and South American women who were removed from their home town in North Korea, Korea, Philippines, Russia, Bolivia, Peru, Mongolian, China, Bangladesh, Kirghiz, Uzbekistan and others to be coerced or trafficked into sexual slavery by Korean government from 1951. 

(I made this draft based on various documents. For example, "to be coerced" depends on the article on NYT(2009.1.8) and others.)

「1923 年から 1945 年にかけて、20 万人以上の


(この記載に関しては様々な資料を基に作成しています。例えば「強制的に性奴隷にされた」というのは 2009年1月8日のNYT記事もソースの一部です。)

  As I mentioned earlier, the history of comfort women for US Army is over half-century long. It is much more likely that their total number reached "MORE THAN 200,000".

Korean government should do what they have asked Japan to do at once. It is much the same for the US politicians who have give countenance to "comfort women".

Royce, the chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee stated following about comfort women problem. "..  to get the past right. Those here recognize that confronting this issue is the right thing to do."

Now is the time for action. He should demonstrate what he said by his action! He should begin to discuss how US government should apologize and make reparation for comfort women for US Army at the committee and the House.

韓国政府は、日本に求めてきたことをただちに実行するべきです。米国で慰安婦の味方をしてきた政治家たちも 同様です。


「…過去を正しく認めること。ここにいる私たちは、この問題に 正しく向き合うべきであることを理解しています。」

この言葉が、真実であることを今こそ行動で証明すべきです! 委員会や下院で謝罪と賠償をどのようにすべきか ただちに議論を始めていただきたい。

Creator :